Regulators in Japan and South Korea have commenced inquiries into the aggressive implications of increasing generative AI markets of their jurisdictions. This follows issues the fast-moving market could shortly be dominated by too few gamers, or that rising anti-competitive practices could develop.
In October, the Japan Honest Commerce Fee started a market examine on generative AI to look at competitors on the infrastructure, mannequin, and utility ranges. As outlined in a dialogue paper, it’ll additionally resolve if modifications could should be made to its Antimonopoly Act and competitors coverage.
SEE: US, UK and EU make joint assertion on fostering AI competitors
The Korea Honest Commerce Fee, in the meantime, launched its personal AI market examine in August of fifty home and worldwide gamers in AI. The KFTC stated it’ll analyse enterprise relations and competitors developments, and preemptively determine points that will undermine competitors and harm shoppers.
Japan taking a look at AI competitors throughout all layers of know-how
Japan’s competitors regulator is anticipating the native generative AI sector to expertise a 47.2% common annual progress charge between 2023 and 2030. For the correct integration of those applied sciences inside its economic system and society, the regulatory physique says it’s “crucial to maintain a fair and competitive environment” in enterprise.
The infrastructure layer
The JFTC is exploring points such because the highly effective dominance of NVIDIA in GPUs, the variations in coaching information worldwide fashions and Japanese fashions use or have entry to, and the problem for Japanese corporations to carry on to AI expertise experience when up in opposition to the monetary firepower of worldwide gamers.
SEE: AI surge might set off international chip scarcity by 2026
The mannequin layer
Japan factors out that, whereas common goal worldwide LLMs lead in areas akin to inferencing, multilingual competence, and multi-model inputs, homegrown gamers are differentiating on Japanese language efficiency or creating specialist LLM fashions for particular enterprise or business use circumstances.
The applying layer
On the product stage — the place companies are creating purposes utilizing both open supply, proprietary, or inner fashions — the JFTC needs to ascertain what obstacles companies face and what challenges exist in sustaining and selling truthful and free competitors within the generative AI market.
Competitors issues embody entry to GPUs
Whereas the JFTC has stated it has not made any conclusions concerning market behaviours in generative AI, there have been quite a few areas that it could be utilizing as a foundation for dialogue with market gamers.
Entry restrictions and exclusion of rivals: If a small variety of giant enterprises are in a greater place to amass GPUs or information, or if entry to different gamers is restricted, then new market entry alternatives and different aggressive dynamics can be impacted, the JFTC famous.
Self-preferencing an organization’s personal providers: One potential abuse of energy in generative AI fashions might happen when the mannequin’s personal providers seem extra favourably in its inference outcomes over these of competing firms, impacting competitors for services available in the market.
Tying service provision to make use of of a mannequin: The JFTC has warned that there could also be issues the place a dominant supplier of a service bundles the usage of its personal generative AI mannequin as a situation of providing that service, thereby impacting competitors amongst generative AI fashions.
Parallel conduct utilizing generative AI: The JFTC has flagged issues that related or an identical pricing methods could emerge from alignment between underlying information and algorithms being utilized by totally different organisations, resulting in an affect on competitors.
Cornering skilled expertise through partnerships: A technique organisations could search to seize the market’s extremely expert expertise for themselves is by forming partnerships, which the JFTC stated might end in results that have been much like a enterprise switch, attracting competitors consideration.
Korea to look at AI market share focus
Whereas acknowledging generative AI could possibly be a big driver of financial progress, South Korea’s competitors regulator is worried that the capital and compute intensive nature of AI know-how offers rise to competitors issues. Like Japan, Korea’s announcement notes potential dangers together with:
- A handful of highly effective firms controlling most market share in AI.
- Potential boundaries to entry constructed by lack of entry to key inputs for AI improvement.
The Commerce Fee is utilizing provisions in its Monopoly Regulation and Honest Commerce Act to launch the examine on the key gamers available in the market. The investigation will study enterprise actions, items and providers throughout the AI sector, and any unfair commerce practices, it stated within the assertion asserting the examine.
Following the investigation, it expects to take a look at competitors coverage that may help innovation and truthful competitors within the AI business, and publish an AI Coverage Report by the tip of 2024.
Australia can be watching generative AI competitors
Australia’s competitors regulator, the Australian Competitors and Shopper Fee, has additionally indicated it’s watching AI market developments. The tenth report in its Digital Platform Companies Inquiry, resulting from be delivered to the federal government in March 2025, will study points of generative AI competitors.
The assertion stated: “The ACCC proposes to look at potential competitors points referring to generative AI. These could embody the excessive boundaries to entry available in the market and the potential for big digital platforms to strengthen and increase their market energy by the combination of Massive Language Fashions (LLMs).
ACCC Chair Gina Cass-Gottlieb stated the physique is “following recent developments in generative AI closely.”
“Adoption has been extensive, and this technology continues to expand and develop at a rapid pace,” she stated. “Generative AI products and services may present new opportunities, but also new challenges with major implications for our work.”
